San Nicolas#2 of 2 hotels in San Nicolas

Astoria Hotel & Restaurant

★★★½☆3.7 out of 5 · 7 reviews

3.5★

Photo: © Albyfli via TripAdvisor

About

The Astoria sits in San Nicolas, Aruba's southernmost town, about a half-hour from the main resort strips. It ranks second of two hotels here, and the 3.7 overall tells only part of the story—rooms and cleanliness both score 1.0, while service and value land at a more respectable 3.0. The seven reviews suggest a small operation with uneven upkeep. San Nicolas itself is worth the drive if you're after something that feels less like a postcard. The town has murals, local bars, and Charlie's Bar, which is older than most of the high-rises. The Astoria gives you a base in that world, but expect basics and manage expectations on the condition of the space. If you need reliable air conditioning and fresh linens, look north. If you're the type who can roll with rough edges for the sake of location and price, it might work for a night or two.

At a glance

Area: San Nicolas
Star rating: ★★★½☆
Typical nightly: $200
Beach access: shuttle
Kid-friendly: ●●●○○
Party score: ●●●○○
Walkability: ●●○○○
Rooms: 100
Casino: –
Swim-up: –
Kids' club: –
All inclusive: –
Vibe: quaint
charming
boutique

Photos

Astoria Hotel & Restaurant at TripAdvisor

Recent Pulse

We're still listening.

We'll show you what travelers are saying about this spot as soon as enough recent reviews come in. Check back shortly.

Similar resorts

San Nicolas●○○○© KamLiCh via TripAdvisor

Kite-Inn

Kite-Inn sits in San Nicolas, the south-east town that still feels like old Aruba — refinery history, local murals, away from the hotel strip. It's the top-rated specialty lodging in the area, and that 4.9 value score makes sense: you're paying budget-tier rates for a small property that delivers on the basics. The sleep quality and service ratings hold steady near the top, and with roughly a hundred rooms it's large enough to have infrastructure but still feels low-key. There's no beach on-site — San Nicolas is more working-town than resort coastline — but a shuttle runs guests where they need to go. The party score is minimal, the walkability is limited, so plan on having a car or leaning into the quiet. If you want all-inclusive or swim-up bars, this isn't it. If you want a cheap, well-run base near Baby Beach and Rodgers Beach without the Eagle Beach crowds, it works.

quiet

San Nicolas●●●●© Management via TripAdvisor

Secrets Baby Beach Aruba

Secrets Baby Beach Aruba sits at the island's southeastern tip in San Nicolas, close to the protected cove that gives it the name. It's the top-ranked property in the area, though San Nicolas only has two hotels to begin with — this is the quiet, industrial side of Aruba, not the high-rise strip. The all-inclusive model here skews adult (couples-only), and the subratings show where it delivers: sleep quality clocks in at 4.6, cleanliness at 4.7. Rooms score 4.5, which suggests they've kept up the product since opening. At the $$$$ tier, you're paying for the seclusion and the package — unlimited food, drinks, and activities bundled in. Service and value both land at 4.0–4.2, so not flawless but functional. Baby Beach itself is a five-minute walk, shallow and calm, good for snorkeling. You're about a 25-minute drive from the airport and farther still from Oranjestad's restaurants, so plan accordingly if you want to leave the grounds.

Adults only

All inclusive

Wide open spaces at our Eagle Beach Location

Eagle Beach●●●●© Management via TripAdvisor

Bucuti & Tara Beach Resort Aruba

Bucuti & Tara sits on the quieter stretch of Eagle Beach, and it's adults-only by design. That #1 ranking among Palm-Eagle Beach hotels isn't decorative — the numbers back it up across location, service, and cleanliness, all sitting at 4.9 out of 5. Sleep quality and rooms both land at 4.8, which makes sense once you see the property: low-density, beachfront, built for the kind of guest who wants the sand without the pool party soundtrack. Back-to-back Travelers Choice Best of the Best awards in 2025 and 2026 confirm what the nearly 11,000 reviews suggest: people return, and they tell others to book. The price level is top-tier, and the value subrating reflects that — still solid at 4.6, but you're paying for the category it occupies. Service scores mirror the location and cleanliness ratings, meaning the staff-to-guest ratio shows. If you want Eagle Beach access without family chaos and you're willing to spend accordingly, this is the benchmark property.

Adults only

Restaurants nearby

Savaneta

The Flying Fishbone

The Flying Fishbone is on the beach in Savaneta, and the setup is adults-only French-Caribbean fusion with tables literally in the water at high tide. That #2 ranking among Savaneta restaurants comes with the second-highest review count in the area, and the 4.9 atmosphere score reflects the whole point of coming here — it's romantic in a way that feels less engineered than the high-rise strip options. The food is seafood-forward, competently done, though the 4.3 value score tells you what you need to know: people debate whether the setting justifies the tier-4 pricing. Service scores well, the French influence shows up in the preparations, and the Caribbean ingredients keep it from feeling like imported fine dining. Reservations are required. If you're booking sunset, know that earlier seatings before 7pm can mean harsh direct light — the magic hour matters here more than at indoor spots.

Savaneta

Zeerovers

Zeerovers is a fisherman's shack on the water in Savaneta, and it's about as straightforward as eating gets. You order fried fish by the pound from whatever came off the boat that morning, grab a picnic table on the pier, and eat. The 4.6 value rating makes sense — prices are low, portions are generous, and the seafood is fresh because the boats are right there. The #4 ranking in Savaneta and the 2025 Travelers' Choice award reflect consistent execution more than anything fancy. The atmosphere is open-air Caribbean casual, which means plastic chairs, ceiling fans, and pelicans circling overhead. Service is quick once your order's up, though weekends can stretch the wait. Families do fine here — it's loud, relaxed, and kids can watch the fishing boats come in. Bring cash if you can. The line moves, but it moves at island speed. If you want tablecloths or a wine list, this isn't it. If you want good fried fish without the markup, it is.

San Nicolas

Kamini's Kitchen

Kamini's Kitchen sits in San Nicolas, the island's southeast art district, and it ranks #1 among restaurants in the area for a reason. The food rating is 4.8 out of 5, and that tracks with what you're getting: Caribbean cooking that doesn't feel touristy. The space has a local vibe, and the service and value ratings both hit 4.7, which is the kind of consistency that earns a Travelers' Choice award. The menu is straightforward Caribbean, portions are generous, and the price sits in the mid-range without the resort markup. Families show up here, which tells you something about the atmosphere and the flexibility of the menu. You don't need a reservation, but with over 1,700 reviews holding that rating, expect a wait if you come at peak hours. San Nicolas is a 20-minute drive from the hotel strip, so this is the kind of place you seek out on purpose, not stumble into.

Source: TripAdvisor · view on TripAdvisor →

Photos by individual contributors as credited above.

Review summaries are AI-paraphrased from public traveler reviews.